Tuesday, October 8, 2013
"NORTH AND SOUTH: BOOK I" (1985) - Episode Six "1860-1861" Commentary
"NORTH AND SOUTH: BOOK I" (1985) - EPISODE SIX "1860-1861" Commentary
We finally come to the last episode of the 1985 miniseries, "NORTH AND SOUTH: BOOK I". And it is a doozy. This is the episode in which the Hazard and Main families unknowingly say good-bye to the past and present before their lives are turned upside-down by the American Civil War.
Episode Six opens on Presidential Election Day (November 6, 1860), two days after Lieutenant Billy Hazard's arrival in Charleston, South Carolina; at the end of Episode Five. An excited Brett Main, who had been staying at her sister's home since her quarrel with their brother Orry at the family's plantation, Mont Royal anticipates meeting Billy. Brett's elation over her reunion with her fiancé during a luncheon is dimmed by his anger over Orry's reluctance to approve their marriage, and a violent encounter with a group of pro-secession thugs hired by Ashton to kill Billy. Following Abraham Lincoln's election as the new president, the state of South Carolina begin its preparations to secede from the United States. Before secession can be achieved, George Hazard visits Orry at Mont Royal to mend their estrangement and convince the other man to approve Billy and Brett's upcoming marriage. The two men go to Charleston to inform the engaged couple. Unfortunately, Billy receives orders to report to Fort Moultrie, which turns out to be a protracted stay following South Carolina's secession from the Union. Following Texas' secession a month later, Charles Main resigns from the U.S. Army and heads back home to South Carolina.
Less than two months later, Billy receives orders from his commander, Major Robert Anderson to report to the War Department in Washington D.C. and deliver dispatches. He uses the opportunity to marry Brett at Mont Royal. The wedding finally allows Ashton to plot her revenge against Billy, using Forbes LaMotte's help. Fortunately for Billy, Madeline LaMotte overhears Forbes, his Uncle Justin and friend Preston Smith going over Ashton's plot. With great difficulty and pain from Justin, Madeline escapes from Resolute and heads for Mont Royal to warn the Mains. Billy and Brett are ambushed by Forbes and Preston on their way to the rail stop. Just as Billy and Forbes engage in a duel that would have left the former with a useless pistol, Charles arrives in time to assist his friend. The conflict ends with Forbes' death at Billy's hand, Justin bereft of his nephew and wife, and Ashton banished from Mont Royal by Orry. In April 1861, Orry mortgages Mont Royal to return money that George had invested in their sawmill. During his journey north, Major Anderson had been forced to surrender his command at Fort Sumter. With small difficulty, Orry arrives at Lehigh Station, where he meets George and Constance's new daughter. Also, a vengeful Virgilia incites a mob to attack the Hazard home and lynch Orry. Fortunately, George manages to intimidate his neighbors into calling off the attack. Virgilia leaves Belvedere for the last time with some loot in hand. And George and Orry bid each good-bye before the latter departs Lehigh Station for his journey back to South Carolina.
I must say that "NORTH AND SOUTH: BOOK I" certainly ended with a bang. And a very satisfied one. There were some problems. I found Terri Garber's performance in a scene that featured Ashton's rant against Brett and Billy rather hammy. She gave a great performance throughout most of the miniseries. But this one scene was probably her weakest moment. I was very curious over Elkhannah Bent's appearance in Washington D.C. on the day of President Lincoln's inauguration. He was still wearing a U.S. Army uniform, despite the fact that his home state of Georgia had already seceded two months earlier. In fact, I found it surprising that Charles Main did not resign from the Army, until two months after South Carolina's secession. The miniseries continued its irritating habit of expressing an erroneous length of time for the period Madeline La Motte was being drugged by her husband. But the episode's real problem proved to be the character of Forbes LaMotte, nephew of Justin LaMotte.
I had no problems with actor William Ostrander's portrayal of Forbes. He gave a subtle and skillful performance. This was especially apparent in one scene in which Forbes, Justin and Preston discussed Ashton's plan to have Billy murdered. David Carradine was fine, despite a few hammy moments. On the other hand, David Weaver's portrayal of Preston Smith struck me as rather stagey . . . over-the-top. Only Ostrander managed to project any villainy with real subtlety. While watching Episode Six, I found myself wondering why Forbes had even bothered to help Ashton kill Billy. Why? I understood why in Jakes' novel. The literary Forbes was in love with Brett. He did not take her rejection of him no better than Ashton took Billy's rejection. I never got the impression that Forbes was in love with either Brett or Ashton in the miniseries. Forbes seemed to regard Brett's rejection as a minor annoyance. And his feelings toward Ashton seemed to be based on pure lust and amusement. So why did he agree to murder Billy on Ashton's behalf? The screenwriters' portrayal of Forbes is probably one of the miniseries' major failures.
However, I still regard Episode Six as one of the miniseries' better chapters. Once again, Richard T. Heffron proved his talent for directing crowd scenes. I was especially how he handled the growing frenzy and chaos of "secession fever" that permeated Charleston in two scenes - namely Billy and Brett's encounter with street thugs and the night Charleston announced South Carolina's secession from the Union. Ironically, the latter sequence began in Ashton's dining room, where Brett, Orry and George heard the bells of St. Michael's Church announced the secession. This latter sequence not only benefited from Heffron's depiction of the celebration in the streets, but also the Mains and George's somber reaction to the news. Other first-rate crowd scenes were in the sequence featuring Orry's northbound journey to Lehigh Station. They include the announcement of Major Anderson's surrender of Fort Sumter on a train headed for Philadelphia, Orry's encounter with fervent Unionists in that city, and his and George's encounter with a lynch mob instigated by Virgilia. The miniseries also featured one exceptional action sequence - namely Ashton and Forbes' attempt to murder Billy. From the moment Ashton learned of Billy and Brett's departure from Mont Royal to Forbes' death at the hands of Billy, this sequence crackled with energy, excellent pacing and suspension; thanks to Heffron's direction and a well-written score by Bill Conti. The episode also benefited from Stevan Larner's sweeping photography, especially in the secession sequences and the one featuring the murder attempt on Billy. In fact Larner earned a well-deserved Emmy nomination for his work in this episode. Vicki Sánchez offered some lovely costume designs for this episode. I was veryenamored of two particular designs worn by Terri Garber and Wendy Kilbourne:
But this day dress worn by Genie Francis really appealed to me:
Like the miniseries' other episodes, the dramatic scenes for Episode Six proved to be its pride and joy. Both James Read and Patrick Swayze provided some of their best moments in two scenes - one that featured George Hazard's visit to South Carolina in the episode's first half, and the other that featured Orry Main's perilous journey to Pennsylvania. John Stockwell had his best moment as Billy Hazard in a scene that featured Billy's anger over Orry's refusal to approve Brett's marriage to him. He had ample support from Genie Francis. I also enjoyed Jonathan Frakes and Wendy Fulton's performances in a scene in which Stanley and Isabel Hazard discussed their plans to take over Hazard Iron during George's absence during the war. It is a pity that Fulton did not reprise her role as Isobel. Both Mary Crosby and Deborah Rush gave solid performances, but Fulton seemed to personify the literary character. Hal Holbrook made his first appearance as President Abraham Lincoln in a fine and subtle performance - a skill that he will maintain in "NORTH AND SOUTH: BOOK II". However, the best dramatic scene featured Constance Hazard's attempt to convince her sister-in-law Virgilia to stay with the family in Lehigh Station, following the debacle with the lynch mob. Both Wendy Kilbourne and Kirstie Alley performed the hell out of that scene.
Despite certain flaws I had detected in Episode Six, I must admit that I really enjoyed it. The episode not only featured some exciting historical moments and a first-rate action sequences, but also some excellent dramatic scenes that brought out the best in producer David L. Wolper, director Richard T. Heffron and the cast. Episode Six proved to be the first example of how all three miniseries seemed to end on a positive note, production wise. "NORTH AND SOUTH: BOOK I" might be flawed, it is still a joy to watch and one of my favorite miniseries of all time.